Our Favorite Local Pizza Places

There's a lot of competition for best pizza in {Town}, but here are some of our favorites

August 10, 2021

Oh, pizza. How we love you. Let us count the ways: Pizza makes dinner a breeze on the nights when cooking is just not gonna happen. No one in the family ever complains about pizza night, and pizza is DELICIOUS.

Pass me another slice, please.

We are lucky we have a lot of locally-owned great pizza shops loaclly to satisfy any and all pizza cravings. Here are our 10 favorite locally-owned spots for pizza:

Mama Angelina's

1251 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Hauppauge, NY 11788

Phone: (631) 360-1463

What we love:Pizza & Southern Italian standards in a casual strip-mall space, with weekly pasta & chicken deals.

Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant

555 NY-111, Hauppauge, NY 11788

Phone: (631) 724-6663

What we love: Casual strip-mall restaurant & pizza parlor attracts crowds with hearty helpings of Italian staples.

Buona Sera

88 E Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787

Phone: (631) 265-0625

What we love: Friendly eatery & pizzeria dishes huge Italian portions with popular pasta deals & gluten-free fare.

Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

40 E Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787

Phone: (631) 724-0210

What we love: Vibrant eatery offering a mix of pizza styles & traditional Italian mains plus a full bar & takeout.

Rocco's Pizza

429 NY-25A, St James, NY 11780

Phone: (631) 862-1600

What we love: No-frills counter-serve pizzeria offering standard pies & pasta entrees, plus delivery.


348 Lake Ave # 3, St James, NY 11780

Phone: (631) 862-6161

What we love: It was super clean inside.  The staff was extremely friendly.  My food was great. 

Sundried Tomato Cafe & Pizzeria

127 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset, NY 11767

Phone: (631) 366-6310

What we love: Big helpings of pasta & Italian faves lure local crowds, plus a pizza counter with specialty pies.


248 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset, NY 11767

Phone: (631) 724-0726

What we love: Neighborhood family friendly pizzeria/ restaurant Everything from healthy salads to great pizza and entrees.


2201 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725

Phone: (631) 462-6267

What we love: A mix of classic pastas, pizza & creative Italian entrees in an upbeat, modern strip-mall space.

Giovanni's Pizza In Commack

149 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725

Phone: (631) 486-6682

What we love:Pizza Delivery, Italian Dinners, Italian Hero's, Catering.